Custom Printing Showdown: AS Colour vs American Apparel T-Shirts
Published on 21/03/2026 by Xpromo Teamβ’ AS Colour T-Shirts, American Apparel T-Shirts
A detailed comparison of AS Colour vs American Apparel t-shirts, focusing on print quality, fabric, fit, and cost-helping you choose the best blank apparel for custom printing.
When it comes to custom printing, not all blank t-shirts are created equal. The shirt you choose directly impacts print quality, durability, and how your brand is perceived. Two of the most popular options in the premium blank apparel space are AS Colour and American Apparel-but which one is actually better for custom printing?
In this in-depth guide, we break down everything you need to know-from fabric and fit to print performance and cost-so you can confidently choose the right t-shirt for your business, brand, or project.
Why Your T-Shirt Choice Matters for Custom Printing
Choosing the wrong t-shirt can ruin even the best design.
Hereβs why it matters:
- Print quality: Fabric affects how ink absorbs and appears
- Durability: Some shirts hold prints longer after washing
- Brand perception: Cheap shirts feel cheap-premium shirts elevate your brand
- Customer retention: Better shirts get worn more often
π Bottom line: your blank t-shirt is just as important as your design.
Brand Overview: AS Colour vs American Apparel
AS Colour Overview
AS Colour has built a strong reputation in the premium blank apparel space. Itβs widely used by:
- Streetwear brands
- Print shops
- Businesses looking for high-quality merch
Key strengths:
- Consistent sizing and quality
- Heavier, structured fabrics
- Premium retail feel
American Apparel Overview
American Apparel is a well-known legacy brand with a fashion-forward identity. Itβs especially popular for:
- Soft, retail-style garments
- DTG printing
- Lifestyle and fashion brands
Key strengths:
- Ultra-soft fabrics
- Lightweight feel
- Modern, fitted cuts
Fabric & Material Comparison (Critical for Printing)
AS Colour Fabric Quality
- Typically heavier GSM (180-220+)
- Ringspun cotton for durability
- Structured feel-holds shape well
- Less prone to twisting or warping
π Ideal for brands wanting a premium, long-lasting product
American Apparel Fabric Quality
- Generally lighter GSM (130-180)
- Softer, combed cotton
- More flexible and drapey
- Vintage-style feel
π Ideal for brands prioritizing comfort and softness
Which Fabric Prints Better?
- Screen Printing: AS Colour wins (better ink hold, sharper results)
- DTG Printing: American Apparel often excels (softer fibers absorb ink well)
- Durability: AS Colour lasts longer after repeated washes
Fit, Style & Market Positioning
AS Colour Fit
- Slightly structured and modern
- Works well for streetwear and premium brands
- Maintains shape after multiple washes
American Apparel Fit
- Slimmer, fashion-forward cut
- Softer drape on the body
- Appeals to retail and lifestyle audiences
Which Is Better for Your Audience?
- Streetwear / Premium brands β AS Colour
- Fashion / lifestyle brands β American Apparel
- Corporate or promotional β depends on budget and feel
Print Quality Comparison (Most Important Section)
Screen Printing Results
- AS Colour: Crisp, vibrant prints Excellent ink adhesion Long-lasting results
- Crisp, vibrant prints
- Excellent ink adhesion
- Long-lasting results
- American Apparel: Good results but slightly less structured surface May feel softer but less bold
- Good results but slightly less structured surface
- May feel softer but less bold
π Winner: AS Colour
DTG (Direct to Garment) Results
- AS Colour: Good detail but slightly less absorption
- Good detail but slightly less absorption
- American Apparel: Excellent color vibrancy Better for complex, full-color designs
- Excellent color vibrancy
- Better for complex, full-color designs
π Winner: American Apparel
DTF & Heat Transfer
- Both perform well
- AS Colour offers better stability
- American Apparel offers softer feel
π Tie (depends on preference)
Embroidery Compatibility
- AS Colour: Strong, stable base (ideal for embroidery)
- American Apparel: Softer fabric may shift slightly
π Winner: AS Colour
Pricing & Value Breakdown
AS Colour Pricing
- Higher upfront cost
- Premium positioning
- Better long-term value
American Apparel Pricing
- Mid to premium pricing
- Slightly more accessible
- Great for retail-style brands
Cost vs ROI
- Cheap option = less wear = less exposure
- Premium option = more wear = higher ROI
π Investing more often leads to better brand visibility over time
Best Use Cases: Which One Should You Choose?
Choose AS Colour Ifβ¦
- You want a premium, structured t-shirt
- Youβre building a streetwear or high-end brand
- You plan to use screen printing or embroidery
- You prioritize durability and longevity
Choose American Apparel Ifβ¦
- You want a soft, retail-style feel
- You focus on DTG printing
- Youβre targeting a fashion-forward audience
- You prioritize comfort and drape
Pros and Cons Summary
AS Colour Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Premium quality
- Excellent for screen printing
- Durable and long-lasting
- Strong brand perception
Cons:
- Higher cost
- Slightly less soft than competitors
American Apparel Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Ultra-soft feel
- Great for DTG printing
- Fashion-forward fits
- Retail-ready
Cons:
- Less durable over time
- Lighter fabric may feel less premium
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Choosing based on price alone
- Ignoring your printing method
- Not aligning with your target audience
- Skipping test samples before bulk orders
Expert Tips for Custom Printing Success
- Always match fabric to printing method
- Order samples before committing
- Think long-term: will customers wear it repeatedly?
- Focus on wearability, not just branding
FAQs
Is AS Colour better than American Apparel for printing?
It depends on the method. AS Colour is better for screen printing and embroidery, while American Apparel performs better with DTG printing.
Which t-shirt is best for DTG printing?
American Apparel is often preferred due to its softer fabric and better ink absorption.
Are AS Colour shirts worth the higher price?
Yes. Their durability and premium feel often result in more wear and better long-term brand exposure.
Do American Apparel shirts shrink or fade?
They can shrink slightly if not cared for properly, especially due to their lighter fabric.
What is the best blank t-shirt for a clothing brand?
For premium brands, AS Colour is a top choice. For softer, fashion-focused brands, American Apparel is a strong option.
Conclusion
Thereβs no one-size-fits-all answer in the AS Colour vs American Apparel debate. The right choice depends on your printing method, audience, and brand positioning.
- Choose AS Colour for durability, structure, and premium branding
- Choose American Apparel for softness, comfort, and DTG-friendly designs
π The best custom t-shirt isnβt just about cost-itβs about how often it gets worn.